Where to Find the Best Cupcakes in New York City

We love the elegant cupcakes at Crumbs, http://www.crumbs.com/, and the pastel Sex and the City confections at Magnolia Bakery,  http://www.magnoliabakery.com/home.php, and are grateful for their many outlets throughout the city.  But if you’re interested in trying some other NYC faves, this cupcake guide’s for you.  This fall, forego boring apple and pumpkin pies and bring any of these little pieces of heaven to your Thanksgiving fest.  Your family will be sure to show you extra thanks this year!




Butter Lane: This East Village bakery does only one thing, and it does it right: cupcakes. Butter Lane focuses on producing a quality cupcake, using only the best ingredients such as pure cocoa and dark chocolate, real vanilla beans, fresh fruit, and local dairy products.  Come in and compare the bakery’s two types of buttercreams—French (made with egg whites, butter, and granulated sugar) and American (made with confectioners’ sugar and butter).  We recommend the vanilla cupcake with the pumpkin icing, this season’s star of the show. ($3/cupcake)

123 East Seventh Street; 212.677.2880; http://www.butterlane.com/index.html
Butter Lane Cupcake

Sugar Sweet Sunshine: Step into this funky bakery and enjoy the retro vibe and the retro cupcake prices. (Cupcakes are only $1.50 or $1 for minis!) The Sexy Red Velvet and Sassy Red Velvet are classics, but the Pumpkin and Pistachio sound like the perfect complements for holiday tables.

126 Rivington Street; 212.995.1960; http://www.sugarsweetsunshine.com/

Sweet Revenge: Cupcake bakeries may have popped up all around the city, but Sweet Revenge stands tall as the city’s only cupcake, beer, and wine bar. Known for its cupcake and wine or beer pairings and its tantalizing happy hour (Sangria/Pinot Noir/Sauvignon Blanc and a cupcake for $10), Sweet Revenge also offers a bistro menu and other scrumptious desserts. The signature Sweet Revenge cupcake (peanut butter cake, ganache filling, peanut butter frosting) sounds perfect for holidays, as does the Nog cupcake (eggnog cake with spice cream cheese frosting), and the Pumpkin Spice cupcake (pumpkin cake with cinnamon cream cheese frosting). ($3.50/cupcake)

62 Carmine Street; 212.242.2240; http://www.sweetrevengenyc.com/
Cupcake and Wine

Cupcake Stop: Food trucks have been all the rage this year, and Cupcake Stop has certainly become an instant favorite. Stalk down the truck’s location on Twitter and spice up your day with any of the cupcakes from the fall collection: Sweet Potato Pie (roasted sweet potato cake, toasted hazelnut frosting, toasted walnut, mini marshmallow), Hummingbird (fresh banana and pineapple cake, cream cheese frosting, toasted walnut garnish, toasted walnuts), Carrot Cake (carrot cake filled with raisins, cream cheese frosting infused with carrot shavings, toasted walnuts), and Apple Pie A La Mode (caramelized spiced apple cake, scoop of vanilla buttercream, homemade caramel drizzle).

973.744.2400; http://www.cupcakestop.com/; http://twitter.com/cupcakestop for locations

Butch Bakery: For cupcakes with an extra shot of testosterone, Butch Bakery is the place to order from. Butch Bakery prides itself in creating “manly cupcakes.”  You won’t find any cutesy treats from Butch Bakery, but each of the 12 offerings is more decadent than the next. The Jackhammer (chocolate cake, chocolate hazelnut filling, hazelnut buttercream), Big Papi (cinnamon spice cake, dulce de leche filling), and Campout (graham cracker cake, marshmallow filling, milk-chocolate ganache) are the perfect holiday gifts for that “manly man” in your life. Boxes, aptly named “rounds” range from $17.50 to $48.00 per box.  No storefront yet – all cupcakes are delivered to your home.

(Made to order cupcakes only) 646.221.3477; www.butchbakery.com
Butch Bakery Cupcakes

Bookmark and Share

5 Responses to “Where to Find the Best Cupcakes in New York City”

  1. [...] Go to source Post Published: 12 November 2010 Author: Food Dude Found in section: Food [...]

  2. Jill says:

    Saw the founder on Rachael Ray a few weeks ago…love the entrepreneurial spirit and creativity people are having in these tough times. I think he was a lawyer just like the guy that started Cupcake Stop. Love it!

  3. Sara says:

    I definitely prefer the French buttercream at Butter Lane! The best!

  4. Jill, moving away from the professional and corporate world to do something creative like this makes lots of sense to me. Watch for more cupcake spots popping up soon.

  5. [...] last winter.  We started with a trip to Santa at Macy’s, saw the Christmas windows and had a coffee (for me) and a cupcake (for my eight year old) across the street from Rockefeller Plaza.  It was your stereotypical day [...]

Leave a Reply

Planning a trip to NYC?